Re: Essais presse (en anglais) de la gamme Vantage
Publié : 29/06/2017
Aston Martin V8 Vantage

Maker: Aston Martin
Predecessor: No Published on 5 Oct 2005 All rights reserved.

All the good changes happened recently at Aston should be down to Ulrich Bez, the Aston boss who had been the father of Porsche 993 during his long service at the German sports car maker. Bez knows so well what made Porsche so successful - quality, image and character, apart from performance and driving fun. I guess he should also know his flyweight company cannot match Porsche in engineering expertise. No wonder he doesn't like to call the V8 Vantage a 911 fighter. Unfortunately, almost all motoring writers do this, and many compare both cars side by side to find out which one is better. And you can guess the result. Yes, Aston may be David, but Porsche is far smarter than Goliath.
Sorry for telling you the result so early, but I just want to say we had better to understand V8 Vantage. At £80,000, it is in a segment where subjective feeling like image and character dominate the buying habit. If you think a 911 Carrera S is better simply because it goes faster, handles better and £15,000 cheaper, then you would be wrong. Does the 911 possess a look so beautiful as the Aston? does its cabin feel as bespoke as the Aston? can it match the rarity of the Aston? when you spend so much money, do you want to be treated as a royal customer, or just one of the 100,000 customers every year purchasing a Porsche vehicle?

The car shares the VH platform with DB9 to make cost feasible. Because it switches to a small-capacity V8 instead of the big V12, the engine can be mounted further back and, when mated to the rear mounted transaxle, achieves an excellent balance of 49:51 front to rear. The 2-seater chassis is 315 mm shorter than DB9, but the wheelbase is just 140 mm shorter, implying the wheels are pushed towards the corners to aid handling.
The chassis is made of aluminum space frames, bonded by rivets and glue like its sister car. Chassis rigidity is increased to 27,000 Nm/degree. The body consists of various lightweight materials, such as aluminum (doors and bonnet), steel (side panels and rear fenders), composites (front fenders and hatchback) and magnesium (inner door panels). However, the whole car tips the scale at 1570 kg, just 140 kg lighter than DB9. Porsche engineers must be proud that its steel monocoque 911 Carrera S undercuts that by 150 kilograms.

So what did Ulrich Bez bring to Aston?

The desirability starts when you drop in its hand-stitched leather buckets. The V8 Vantage employs a metallic instrument panel and center console almost exactly the same as DB9. The bespoke feel is not mass production sports cars like Porsche can reproduce.

I suspect the engine sound is one of the secret weapons of Bez to fight against his ex-employer, because it comes at no extra cost and it lets the V8 Vantage feel faster than it is. In fact, the car cannot keep up with Carrera S, let alone GT3 and the similarly priced 911 Turbo. BMW M6 is also faster. But these German cars have a common problem: they are mass production, or based on a mass production model. People buy them to exploit their performance. In contrast, the baby Aston is more like Ferrari (its production rate is the same as F430) - people buy them to enjoy their style and character, plus the premium image they deliver.

On the other hand, the V8 Vantage also rides and handles brilliantly. Compare with the stiffly sprung DB9, the baby Aston rides much more comfortable, thanks to the lighter engine, stronger chassis and the extra time it spent to refine the damping. The ride is firm but supple enough to be a long distance cruiser. On poorly surfaced B roads, it is even more absorbent than the 911 Carrera S.

That said, Porsche 911 Carrera S is even sharper – its steering has more feedback at lock, its tires provide more traction, its brakes are more powerful, and it corners with higher limit than the Aston can manage. The margin is small, but in every objective area the German car outperforms the British car even though it is considerably cheaper. It proves that Porsche is still the standard of sports car industry.
However, the high level of precision, refinement and user friendliness achieved by the baby Aston is already sufficient to impress its wealthy target customers. Then they will consider the subjective aspects – design, engine sound, exclusivity.... Bez knows this business very well. Verdict:





The best handling Aston ever made...
Have you ever heard Aston Martin mentioned how fast its cars lapped Nurburgring Nordschleife ? Five years ago no one could have imagined that, because the British luxury sports car brand used to stress brutal power and impeccable craftsmanship more than anything else. But time as changed since German guy Ulrich Bez sitting at the top of the company. He copied the know-how trained in Porsche to Gaydon and started measuring the absolute performance of his cars according to Nurburgring lap time. In this way, a sportier version of V8 Vantage was produced. It lapped Nurburgring Nordschleife in less than 8 minutes, which matched a 911 Carrera S. Aston would call it N400, where N stands for Nurburgring and 400 is the horsepower count. Some 480 units of this car will be produced before most of its technology is transferred to the production V8 Vantage. Each one will cost 13 percent more than the standard car.
Externally, the V8 Vantage N400 doesn't differ much from the regular car. What impress us most are the tuned engine and suspensions. The 4280 cc V8 gets a smoother intake system and revised engine management program to liberate more power from the mid-range to the top end. Now it generates 400 horsepower at 7300 rpm instead of 380 hp / 7000 rpm. Maximum torque increases a little bit as well. Subjectively, the engine feels livelier than the numbers suggested. However, Aston claims 0-60 mph is reduced by only 0.1 seconds while top speed is increased by 2 mph.
That means most of the reduction in lap time is down to the suspension upgrade. Stiffer springs (40% up at front and 30% up at the rear), stiffer dampers and thicker rear anti-roll bars improves the body control a lot, resulting in flat cornering and excellent high-speed stability. Amazingly, the ride quality is actually improved over the regular V8 Vantage, thanks to the well-judged damping as well as the lower unsprung mass contributed by lighter alloy wheels. Unquestionably, N400 is the best handling Aston ever made. However, a 911 Carrera S is considerably cheaper, while GT3 is faster and sharper still. The Aston will need more muscle to justify its price. Verdict:





AM V8 no longer feels second-class to 911 Carrera S and Audi R8...
Soon after the completion of V8 Vantage N400, Aston Martin introduced an evolutionary upgrade to the whole V8 Vantage line. This is certainly not a “facelift”, because apart from a different wheel design there is no changes at all to the exterior – no complaints here, considering how good the V8 Vantage always looks. There are some refinements made to the interior, but they are too minor to be mentioned in AutoZine, too. The biggest change is the V8 engine, which has grown from 4.3 to 4.7 liters.
By lengthening the stroke by 5mm and enlarging the bore by 2mm, Ford’s Cologne engine plant (which builds all Aston Martin engines) increased the capacity of the V8 to 4735 cc. Predictably, a larger bore requires larger valves, intake ports and manifolds, while the longer stroke requires a new forged crankshaft and conrods. Cologne also took this chance to lighten the conrods and counter weights to improve engine response. As a result, horsepower has been up by 40 to 420. Max torque is 347 lb-ft, a considerable improvement from the previous 302 lb-ft. Aston claims top speed is raised from 175 mph to 180 mph, while 0-60 mph acceleration is reduced from 4.9 to 4.7 seconds.
In normal driving, you can feel the extra punch from 3500 rpm upwards, but the magnitude (and sound) is not as sensational as the similarly-sized V8 of Maserati GranTurismo S or Alfa Romeo 8C Competizione. Among 2-seater sports cars it is not particularly quick. In fact, it is still slower than Porsche 911 Carrera S, which is quite disappointing because it has a larger engine, a more sophisticated aluminum chassis and a higher price tag. We heard Cologne will build a 5.0-liter version V8 for Jaguar. Why doesn’t Aston Martin employ an engine at least as large ? You know, the name “V8 Vantage” used to refer to a 5.3-liter V8 model, so there is still plenty of space for upgrade.

Why doesn't it employ a 5.0 V8 like the future Jaguar ?
To save the day, at least the new engine is more economical and clean. Fuel economy is improved from 18.8 mpg to 20.4 mpg, while CO2 emission is reduced from 358g/km to 328g/km. Like many other cases, a larger and torquer engine actually reduces fuel consumption as it does not need to be revved so hard.
Apart from engine, Aston also refined the drivetrain by introducing a lighter clutch and flywheel, refined software of Sportshift semi-automatic to improve response in Sport mode and improve smoothness in Comfort mode. That said, this gearbox is still far from world class, thus the standard 6-speed manual is always recommended. At the chassis, suspensions have received stiffer springs (up 11% front and 5% rear), revised upper damper mountings and bump stops and standard low-friction Bilstein dampers. Steering feel and accuracy is improved by revised steering geometry and stiffer bushings at front lower suspension arms. New 19-inch alloy wheels complete the chassis modifications.
On the road, there is a slight improvement to ride and handling. However, to enjoy the full effect you must equip this car with the optional Sports Pack, which includes 45% stiffer springs, retuned dampers and lighter forged alloy wheels. For sure, low speed ride is quite hard, but once you push the car its damping improves, its body control is excellent, its rear end feels more planted and its steering is meaty and responsive. On back roads the AM V8 no longer feels second-class to 911 Carrera S and Audi R8. It still lacks the tactile steering feel of Porsche and the controls are physical compare with Audi, but it is engaging to drive nonetheless. Putting style and exclusivity into the equation, the revised V8 Vantage is still a sensible choice, if not the best of the class objectively. Verdict:



